Gershon Baskin

Israel’s strategic choices regarding Gaza

11.06.2015

Gershon Baskin. Photo: Otmar Steinbicker

Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon, speaking about the Gaza Strip at the Herzliya conference, noted correctly that today Gaza is totally dependent on Israel. Even years after Israel’s disengagement from Gaza, Israel remains in full control of Gaza’s borders, airspace and coastal waters.

The siege on Gaza is a joint Israeli-Egyptian venture that has totally closed Gaza off to the entire world.

Egypt’s siege is more hermetic than Israel’s since the takeover of Egypt by Abdel Fattah Sisi and the demise of the Muslim Brotherhood. Egypt has closed the Rafah border with Gaza almost totally and has destroyed nearly 1,000 tunnels that fueled the Gaza economy. Gazans can no longer travel to the world via Egypt and only a few are allowed to enter Egypt for humanitarian purposes.

Israel’s border with Gaza is also closed to Gazans, except for humanitarian purposes such as emergency health care, which is approved and paid for by the Palestinian Authority. Gazans wishing to travel abroad to attend conferences, for university, or for tourism are not allowed to do so, except in rare cases. The Gazan economy is controlled by imports that Israel allows in from Israel, the West Bank or from abroad. Almost no goods or commodities are allowed to exit Gaza.

Gaza is a lonely island, a tiny territory with 1.8 million people living in what can only be called a prison. The prison keepers are a combination of Israel, Egypt, Hamas and the PA, as well as the complacent international community which does little to ease the situation. The only words to describe the situation of the people of Gaza are hopelessness and despair.

I cannot even imagine what it is like to live in Gaza. It is impossible for me to comprehend how people live there with no hope of a better future. What kind of dreams can young people in Gaza have? There are schools and even at least five working universities. But what can a university graduate in Gaza hope to do with their education? Over the past years I have been approached by Gazans who received scholarships to study abroad. They asked my assistance in getting them permits to enter Israel to attend visa interviews in various embassies and consulates.

In most cases I was able to help. But once they received the visas and had their invitations to attend universities abroad in their hands, the Israeli authorities refused to grant them permits to travel abroad via Israel, even through Jordan, and they remained imprisoned in Gaza with their dreams flushed down the drain. Egypt won’t help them leave either.

Now there is talk in Israel that the continuation of Hamas’s control over Gaza is perhaps the best policy option for Israel. Hamas is facing threats from more radical groups within Gaza and its rocky relationship with Egypt has led to a new Hamas commitment to the Egyptians to fight terrorism threats coming from Gaza into the Sinai. Israel’s military and security chiefs believe that Hamas is there for the long run, so why not try to work out some kind of long-term cease-fire arrangements? Israel, as has been reported, is considering easing the siege on Gaza and even allowing some Gazans to seek employment in Israel once again, as was the case for tens of thousands of Gazans before the disengagement.

These steps are wise and will help ease tensions in Gaza and even perhaps postpone the next round of warfare between Gaza and Israel.

The way that these policy decisions are implemented are perhaps even more important that the policies themselves.

If the policies are aimed at empowering Hamas and sustaining Hamas’s grip on Gaza, then these policies are unwise and should be reconsidered. The need to ease life in Gaza should be coupled with the need to empower moderates at the cost of extremists rather than the other way around. Hamas should not be awarded for its intransigence.

The PA led by Mahmoud Abbas must be the benefactor of policies that will ease the lives of Gazans, even if the PA is waging an international diplomatic offensive against Israel; it has rejected the armed struggle and has no arsenal of missiles or battlefield of tunnels designed to kill Israelis. The choice between Abbas and Hamas is still strongly in favor of Abbas.

Yes it is true that Abbas has no real control in Gaza, but he still wields considerable influence there with an increasing number of Gazans fed up with Hamas rule.

Israeli work permits for Gazans should be administered through the PA in cooperation with Gaza’s private sector business leaders. Israel could demand that Abbas’s PA security forces be reinstated at the Gaza side of the Erez crossing in exchange for granting work permits. The same could be implemented on the Gaza side of Kerem Shalom for goods coming in and out of Gaza and in conjunction with Egypt on the Gaza side of the Rafah crossing.

Hamas would have little choice and would have to agree to these demands. All actions aimed at easing Gaza’s economic pressures should consider the way to empower Gaza’s moderates and the return of the PA to control of Gaza.

In principle the very best way to deal with Gaza would be in the context of a regional plan in which Israel would finally accept the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative as a basis for Israeli-Palestinian peace. In this initiative Israel could request that the Arab Sunni moderate states of the Arab League convene a regional and international summit where Gaza’s future would be placed on the table. A plan could be fostered by Israel, Jordan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, the Emirates and other Gulf States together with the PA on the reintegration of Gaza into the PA including the “decommissioning” of Gaza’s military forces with the assistance of an Arab League-led international force. This is obviously a political process which would take time to develop and build support for, but it could be launched by an Israeli initiative once the Arab Peace Initiative is accepted as the basis.

Temporary moves by Israel to ease life in Gaza, while positive in their intent, must take into account longer- term policy imperatives, which must include the demise of Hamas and other extremists. None of that seems to be on the Israeli agenda, which has done exactly the opposite of what it should be doing – strengthening the extremists at the expense of the moderates. This must change.

Gershon Baskin is the co-chairman of IPCRI, the Israel Palestine Center for Research and Information, a columnist for The Jerusalem Post and the initiator and negotiator of the secret back channel for the release of Gilad Schalit. His new book, Freeing Gilad: the Secret Back Channel, has been published by Kinneret Zmora Bitan in Hebrew.

Gershon Baskin ist Autor des Aachener Friedensmagazins www.aixpaix.de. Seine Beiträge finden Sie hier


World Wide Web aixpaix.de

Beiträge von Gershon Baskin
2016

De-risking peace - Part I

The Left is right

The French connection

The United Nations and Israel’s legitimacy

A moment of opportunity

The darkness of our times

Addressing the core

The worst negotiations, the best negotiations

Palestinian turmoil and Israeli interests

This one is for you - the Palestinians

Palestinian suffering makes no sense for Israel

Creating a compelling vision for peace

It is also in our hands

Sooner or later

There is no partner

There is no partner

2015

Yes, it is difficult to make peace

What does he really want?

To those who oppose Israeli-Palestinian peace

Israel – my sad home

Have I got news for you

It is still not too late for peace

Netanyahu, tell us what you really think!

The partnership challenge

The binational reality that we are experiencing

Abbas is still the leader who can make peace

A new intifada?

After Abbas

The distance between here and peace and security

Doing the wrong thing at that wrong time

The one and only solution!

Yeshayahu Leibowitz was right!

The disengagement – 10 years on: What we choose to forget

Needed - a new approach to Gaza

A bad agreement is better than no agreement

Obviously no peace now, so what then?

Ramadan Kareem!

Israel’s strategic choices regarding Gaza

Anti-normalization hypocrites

FIFA, soccer and the Palestinians

Both sides now

It’s time for Palestine

The citizens’ challenge – from despair to hope

We have the chance to do the right thing in Yarmouks

The world is not against us

This is what you voted for, and this is what you will get

The no decision elections

A cautious peace, but peace nevertheless

For the sake of Israel, Netanyahu must be sent home

Going ballistic even prior to an agreement

To the new IDF chief of staff, Gadi Eisenkot

The Peace Bridge

The choices we must make

Israeli elections – It’s not about the economy

Threats and security

2014

Returning to negotiations

Our most important elections

The missed opportunities

We want peace, but they don't

Our future is in our hands

Defining who we are

Unlike religious wars, political wars have solutions

Today and tomorrow

If we had a real leader

Jerusalem of peace, Jerusalem of war

No tango going on at all

The Gaza challenge

Is Hamas prepared to end this war with a long-term ceasefire?

The end of the ceasefire, the renewal of war and the end game

The aftermath

Some thoughts this morning

Regional forum for security and stability – Gaza first

After a long phone conversation with a Hamas leader in Gaza

Don’t destroy Gaza, build it!

Framework document for the establishment of permanent peace (part 3 of 3)

Framework document for the establishment of permanent peace (part 2 of 3)

Framework document for the establishment of permanent peace

Palestinian refugees in Syria

Annexing the West Bank – a catastrophic plan for the Jewish people

Mutual and reciprocal recognition

Our Palestinians, their Jews

A very personal statement on peace

2013

Contextual reciprocity

Negotiating atmospherics

My Conversation With Hamas

Ramadan Kareem

Wahrheit, Lügen und Rechtmäßigkeit

Kauft palästinensisch!

Rat für den Präsidenten

Keine Fortsetzung des Unilateralismus!

Diesen Weg müssen wir einschlagen!

Die Kluft im Umgang mit den israelischen Arabern schließen

2012

Eine Ein-Staat-Realität ist nicht durchführbar

Strategische Fehler und Herausforderungen

Mord an der Chance für Ruhe

Das Ende des Raketenbeschusses aus Gaza

Die Aufgabe eines Staatsmannes

Es gibt einen Ausweg

Atomwaffen raus aus dem Arsenal

Was Abbas Israel sagen sollte

Obama, gestatte es uns nicht!

Ist mein zionistischer Traum gestorben?